LAWYERS & ACCOUNTANTS WORKING TOGETHER
TCC CASE SHOWS HOW ACCOUNTANTS CAN WORK UNDER SOLICITOR-CLIENT PRIVILEGE
Download a PDF copy of this Blog here.
It has long been understood that only dues paying lawyers can offer their clients the protection of Solicitor-Client Privilege: the right to seek and receive legal advice in confidence, free from compelled disclosure to the Canada Revenue Agency (“CRA”), or even to the courts. Yet, in tax matters, the assistance of an Accountant is sometimes beneficial – or even required – and Canadian law recognizes no similar Accountant-Client Privilege.
A recent Tax Court of Canada (“TCC”) decision shows how Accountants can be retained by Experienced Tax Counsel to assist in providing tax advice and/or litigation support, with their work still benefitting from the protection of Solicitor-Client Privilege.
In this Tax Audit Series Report, we review the decision and the steps needed to keep that protection in place.
The Alaris Decision
In Alaris Equity Partners Inc. v. The King, 2026 TCC 185 (October 28, 2026), the CRA sought production of 14 documents withheld on discovery in General Anti-Avoidance Rule (“GAAR”) appeals involving certain financing transactions from 2008.
In 2008, the taxpayer’s group retained a law firm as Tax Counsel, but with only weeks to deliver the legal advice. Under the time constraints, the law firm engaged Accountants to assist with certain aspects of the work which it believed was required in order to provide its legal advice.
Under a written engagement letter between the law firm and the Accountants, the Accountants were required to gather, review and summarize information on the taxpayer’s corporate structure and historical tax reporting, and produce a “due diligence” report (the “Report”). The issue in this case was whether the Report and related communications were protected by the Solicitor-Client Privilege.
The TCC ultimately agreed that, to a substantive extent, both the Report and related communications between the law firm and the accountants were privileged – mainly on the strength of the engagement agreement, which is evidence that the accountants were acting as an agent for the law firm, and therefore the Report and related communications should be protected under the umbrella of Solicitor-Client Privilege.
The TCC stressed that the accountants acted solely and directly for the law firm, not for the taxpayer – effectively an exclusive agent relationship – providing work that was essential to the legal opinion and of a kind that the law firm could have done itself. In sum, delegating work to Accountants under time pressure did not strip it of privilege.
can attract Solicitor-Client Privilege.
Experienced Tax Counsel will need to be involved to
retain the Accountants!
Takeaways
Where the assistance of an Accountant is required in a tax matter, there is no Accountant-Client Privilege to fall back on, and the accountant’s files will generally be open to the CRA, or even to the courts.
However, when Experienced Tax Counsel is involved, an exclusive agent relationship can be leveraged to onboard that necessary accounting assistance.
For help with Tax Audits, please click here.
For an updated Index of our Tax Audit Series, click here.