
THE INTERSECTION OF TAX & CRIMINALITY
SERIOUS TAX COMPLIANCE ISSUES CAN LEAD TO CRIMINAL PROSECUTIONS
Download a PDF copy of this Blog here.
Many taxpayers are likely unaware that one of the Canada Revenue Agency’s (“CRA”) compliance enforcement tools is pursuing criminal charges under its program legislation (i.e., legislation under the responsibility of the CRA).
In this Tax Evasion Series Report, we review this intersection of tax non-compliance and criminality under the Excise Tax Act (“ETA”) and the Income Tax Act ("ITA"), highlighting the importance of seeking professional legal advice due to the extremely serious consequences of prosecutions for tax evasion under this (and other) CRA legislation.
Tax Evasion-Type Offences Under the ETA & ITA
Potential criminal tax evasion "offences" are found in section s. 327 of the ETA and 239 of the ITA. These offences can include:
- Making false or deceptive statements in a return, certificate, statement etc. required under ETA or ITA or their regulations;
- Destroying, altering or secreting any documents, or making false or deceptive entries or omitting material particulars in a document, for the purpose of evading remittance/payment of tax or obtaining a refund;
- Wilfully attempting to evade compliance with the ETA or ITA or the payment/remittance of tax;
- Conspiring with any person to commit one of the offences described above.
- Wilfully attempting to obtain a rebate or refund without entitlement under Part IX of the ETA.
The potential punishments for these offences are extremely serious and can include fines up to 200% of the tax evaded under both Acts, and imprisonment up to 5 years when prosecuted by indictment!
Both the ETA and ITA also include a number of other offences specific to the Act in question, with significant fines and terms of imprisonment also possible punishments.
Party Liability for Corporations
Notably, where a corporation commits an offence under the ETA or the ITA, directors and officers may be considered parties to the offence: see ETA 330 & ITA 242. In such a scenario, the director or officer is liable on conviction for the punishment provided for the offence in question!
Criminal Code Prosecutions
It is also notable that the CRA may also refer matter to be enforced and charges laid under various provision of the Criminal Code of Canada ("CCC"), including CCC 380 which deals with fraud. Where fraudulent tax losses exceed $1 million, the minimum punishment courts must impose is a two-year term of imprisonment, with the maximum punishment being 14 years in prison!
to Criminal Prosecutions.
Experienced Counsel with BOTH a Tax & Criminal Law
Practice will be required for these matters!
Takeaways
Serious non-compliance with a taxpayer's obligations under the ETA or the ITA (and/ or any other CRA program legislation) can also lead to criminal prosecutions with extremely serious consequences! Navigating this dangerous intersection between tax non-compliance and criminal tax evasion exposure, including the development of possible substantive or due process defences will generally require the immediate retainer of Experienced Counsel with BOTH a Tax & Criminal Practice will be required for these matters.
For help with potential Tax Evasion Issues, please click here.
For an updated Index of our Tax Audit Series, click here.
